The history of mental health has seen a lot of camps and fighting between theoretical perspectives. “My treatment is better than yours”. Or, “you better not talk about how people are affected by thoughts and emotions”. So then, what is the best treatment? Who wins? Researchers have long found evidence for the Dodo Bird Effect – a phenomenon of therapy that answers this question.

There’s no doubt that some treatments work better than others for specific difficulties. For example, research finds that exposure and response prevention is particularly effective for OCD. On the other hand, CBT with exposure based behavioral experiments appears most effective for social anxiety disorder. A “menu” of a few different treatments (but not all treatments) work well for substance use difficulties.

But when you average everything together, research finds that no real established approach is better than any others. For example, on average, CBT does not necessarily perform better than short-term psychodynamic therapy. Researchers coined the term “Dodo Bird Effect” to describe this lack of difference between established therapies.

What research finds about effective therapy

Research finds that there are a few key elements for therapy that do matter to make them share effectiveness. Otherwise, therapy can fall short and be ineffective for clients. First, research shows that structured evidence-based therapies all rise above supportive talk therapy. That is, simply having a client come in and providing good active listening without providing skills they can use to cope is not as effective as having a formulated skills-based approach. (Evidence shows that supportive talk therapy may be somewhat helpful for depression, but not for other difficulties.)

For example, approaches like Interpersonal Therapy (IPT) and behavioral activation for depression are both shown to be effective. CBT and exposure therapies both are highly effective for many difficulties. ACT and DBT both are found to be effective for a difficult set of client struggles. Gottman or emotion-focused approaches both appear helpful for relationship struggles. In particular, modes like Prolonged Exposure therapy, Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT), or EMDR give clients definitive methods to deal with their fight or flight responses in the moment. Otherwise, active listening alone does not give them any tools or strategies to learn how to navigate different trauma triggers and experience relief.

So what is it about these therapies then? Common factors research delved deeper into what makes therapy effective. The research found that the client’s internal resources (e.g., coping skills, motivation, etc) were important. But empathy and unconditional regard that forms a strong therapeutic relationship also emerged as another important factor for effective therapy. This is consistent with research in clinical and social psychology findings that social support is one of the greatest predictors of resilience and well-being.

What the Dodo Bird Effect means for therapy

This is interesting, because you’d think that if you have a strong therapeutic relationship, simply “listening well” could actually be helpful. But we fall short as therapists if we simply listen. We need to provide strategies clients can use to cope.

On the other hand, if we simply provide straight strategies in a rote or unempathetic way, then we also fall short of helping clients. But altogether, research shows that a strong relationship and effective coping strategies are crucial to help clients make real change in their lives. One without the other simply won’t help.

One solution for therapists may be to train in multiple modes of evidence-based therapy. That way, therapists armed with a thorough intake assessment and a working case conceptualization can flexibly call on different approaches to provide specific coping skills clients may need in certain situations.

For example, exposure skills for anxiety clients and behavioral activation skills for depressed clients. But then therapists should also continue to develop and hone in their therapeutic relationship skills. They can also seek continued consultation with colleagues to help navigate difficult relationships or ruptures in rapport.

Clients benefit when they know they have a strong supportive “coach” or “cheerleader” who is “in their corner” and highly supportive. But they also need to be able to learn effective strategies to cope with the struggles they experience when alone. Of course, they are not with us during the vast majority of their week (usually their entire week minus 50 minutes). So both empathy and a strong relationship coupled with coping skills to build their internal resources is the mix that helps them attain actual long-term stable change. Now that’s a great combination.